OK, so when I said "I would" I meant "I would just do it now myself, but I'm trying to be good and productive." But, best laid plans.

It looks like you just have to complete a setlist in each venue, of which most of the cities have three and the special endgame cities have one. Also, YOU, or someone signed in as you, at least, needs to do a set in each one. More specifically, while the set was played, the controller with you signed in had to be actively playing. It might be that one of the setlists you're looking at was somehow played without your profile actively participating, like perhaps Eric was playing solo or something.